Skip to content
  • About
  • Digital Collection
  • Impact
  • Connections and Opportunities
  • About
  • Digital Collection
  • Impact
  • Connections and Opportunities
EN
EN PT
Contact
Back

NFC Accessfor Mobile Payments

Submission to the Competition and Markets Authority (CMА) Consultation on NFC Access Conduct Requirement: Apple’s Mobile Platform
Autor Avtar

Bernardo Fico

  • Autor Avtar
    João Navas
  • Autor Avtar
    Thiago Poloni
Bernardo Fico
  • Author Bernardo Fico, João Navas, Thiago Poloni
17/11/2026
  • Digital Markets Center
CMA NFC – Legal Wings InstituteDownload

This submission examines the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA)’s proposal concerning the terms of access to Near Field Communication (NFC) technology on Apple’s mobile platform, focusing on the relationship between interoperability, security and competition in digital markets. In assessing the scope of the proposed intervention, it considers the characteristics of Secure Element (SE) and Host Card Emulation (HCE) architectures, differentiation between technological ecosystems and the proportionality requirements applicable to regulatory obligations.


Section II first considers security as a dimension of competitive differentiation between digital ecosystems, focusing on the protection of credentials afforded by the SE, the different attributes of HCE and the importance of those attributes to service quality and consumer choice, while distinguishing their preservation from restrictions on alternative architectures.

Section III then examines developments in the European Union, Switzerland and Australia. Their different approaches show that access to NFC infrastructure may be promoted through a range of regulatory measures, without assuming that one technological solution is superior in every context.

Finally, Section IV assesses the proportionality of requiring HCE and SE simultaneously, considering the commercial and operational difficulties identified by the CMA, academic literature on interoperability remedies and the CMA’s own guidance. It considers whether improvements to SE access and access to both architectures would achieve the intended competitive outcomes, taking account of their respective benefits and burdens.

Share

Download

Related Content

If you are interested on this subject, you might also want to read these publications selected by our team.

17/11/2026

  • 4
Report

NFC Accessfor Mobile Payments

Submission to the Competition and Markets Authority (CMА) Consultation on NFC Access Conduct Requirement: Apple’s Mobile Platform

Author

  • Bernardo Fico
  • João Navas
  • Thiago Poloni
  • Author Bernardo Fico, João Navas, Thiago Poloni
  • Digital Markets Center
View
View

10/11/2026

  • 45
Report

Evento de lançamento | Supervisão Parental no ECA Digital

Em 22 de outubro de 2026, o Legal Wings Institute realizou, na Faculdade de Direito da USP, o evento de lançamento do relatório “Supervisão Parental no ECA Digital”.

Author

  • Juliano Maranhão
  • Author Juliano Maranhão
  • Digital Markets Center
View
View

09/11/2026

  • 50
Nota Técnica

Safeguarding Children and Adolescents from Online Radicalisation

Submission to the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security (PJCIS)

Author

  • Bernardo Fico
  • Thiago Poloni
  • Author Bernardo Fico, Thiago Poloni
  • Digital Markets Center
View
View

29/09/2026

  • 78
Video

Diálogos Luso-Brasileiros na Era Digital

No dia 17 de setembro de 2026, a Faculdade de Direito da Universidade de Lisboa recebeu o evento “Diálogos Luso-Brasileiros na Era Digital”, reunindo especialistas do Brasil e de Portugal para discutir temas atuais relacionados à inteligência artificial, regulação e proteção de direitos no ambiente digital.

Author

  • Juliano Maranhão
  • Author Juliano Maranhão
  • Artificial Intelligence and Society Center
View
View

10/09/2026

  • 180
Events

Panel 2 – Building AI Governance: Regulatory Frameworks and Institutional Models in Brazil and China

Panel 2 of the Brazil–China Legal Dialogue on Artificial Intelligence: Governance, Regulation and Innovation

Author

  • Juliano Maranhão
  • Author Juliano Maranhão
  • Artificial Intelligence and Society Center
View
View

09/09/2026

  • 236
Events

Panel 1 – Fostering the AI Economy: Legal Frameworks for Data, Innovation and Digital Infrastructure

Panel 1 of the Brazil–China Legal Dialogue on Artificial Intelligence: Governance, Regulation and Innovation

Author

  • Juliano Maranhão
  • Author Juliano Maranhão
  • Artificial Intelligence and Society Center
View
View

The essential from Legal Wings

Uma seleção do nosso melhor conteúdo, feita para quem tem pouco tempo e muito interesse. Sem ruído, apenas conhecimento.

Follow our social networks for news, publications and debates.

Instagram
Linkedin
Youtube
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use

© Copyright 2026 | Legal Wings –
All rights reserved

Developed by

noomad.global

Back to top

Contact us

contato@legalwings.com.br

Where we are

Travessa Ouro Preto 131

Jardim Paulistano

ZIP CODE 01452-010

São Paulo/SP

Legal Wings ● CNPJ 29.208.690/0001-50

One open door for dialog.

Do you have any questions, suggestions or proposals? We believe that the best ideas come from exchange. Use the form below to send us your message and our team will reply shortly.

Legal Wings ● CNPJ 29.208.690/0001-50

    [polylang hide_current=1 show_flags=0 show_names=1]
EN
  • Home
  • About
  • Digital Collection
  • Impact
  • Connections and Opportunities
  • Home
  • About
  • Digital Collection
  • Impact
  • Connections and Opportunities
Contact

Share this Content

Share this article with your network.

Share on LinkedIn
Share on Whatsapp
Copy Link

Josie Menezes

Director

Location

São Paulo

Bio

Dr. Chen brings over 15 years of experience in legal technology and academic research. She holds a JD from Harvard Law and a PhD in Computer Science from MIT. Her work focuses on the ethical implications of AI in legal systems.

Areas of specialization

Contact
Linkedin

Previous members

Our gratitude goes to the researchers and experts who have dedicated their talents to our mission and have been instrumental in our journey.

João Pedro Nazareth

Pesquisador
Get to know

Antônio Tanure

Pesquisador
Get to know